Lautleise Muster: a small atlas of overlooked disinformation patterns
Disinformation beyond true and false
They are called lautleise (‘loud-quiet’) because they work quietly, yet become loud once you know them. This atlas collects disinformation patterns that get by without a false statement but can be all the more problematic for it. It explores the working definition of the DFG Priority Programme “Rethinking Disinformation” (Re:DIS), under which disinformation is publicly disseminated information that worsens the epistemic situation. The atlas is a work in progress.
Some content is not in itself disinformation – or not disinformation. Whether it is depends, among other things, on for whom, compared to what and in which respect it worsens the epistemic situation.
What counts as content is often more than a single sentence: an answer in relation to the question, a pair of statements, a selection from many reports, or a statement together with the network it is embedded in. For several patterns, the problem lies not in a single piece of information but in its relation to others.
Formal model. The conceptual model and its schema make the working definition precise. (in German)
The questions
-
Assessment
- Finding
- yes · no · contested
- Effect
- worsen · lock in · seal off (none if the finding is no)
- What exactly is the content?a statement · an answer to a question · an explanation · a pair · a selection · a network
- Frame: For whom?
- Compared to what?
- In which respect?What we attend to · Whom we believe · Why we believe · What we believe (not the focus here)
Patterns by dimension
The cards are grouped by the dimension in which the pattern typically makes things worse.
- Dimension What we believe – Which statements we take to be true, and how certain we are. The classic domain of fact-checking – not covered by this atlas
-
Dimension
What we attend to
– What our attention is directed to.
- question shifting (Ablenkung)
- selective salience (Gewichtung & Auslassung)
-
Dimension
Whom we believe
– Which sources we credit with expertise.
- capture of expertise (Kaperung)
- opinion presented as fact (Meinung als Tatsache)
-
Dimension
Why we believe
– On what grounds and by which standards we take something to be right.
- pseudo-explanation (Pseudo-Erklärung)
- double standard (Doppelter Maßstab)
The individual pattern cards are available in German.
German overview · Conceptual model (German)
AI note. I used AI assistants in creating this atlas. I am responsible for the concept, examples and texts myself.